HR Practices to Ensure Fairness and Compliance in Background Checks

2 min read
Fri, Sep 15, 2023

Ensuring fairness and compliance in background checks is crucial for HR professionals to maintain a level playing field for all job candidates. Hiring managers must stay current on employment laws designed to protect both job candidates and employers. These steps help avoid legal implications and create a trustworthy and inclusive work environment. 

Here are HR practices to ensure fairness and compliance in background checks.


Employment Background Check Laws

State and federal laws are enacted to ensure fairness and compliance throughout the hiring process. Some of the laws and guidelines that HR professionals must follow include:

Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA): This federal law sets guidelines for the collection, use, and dissemination of consumer information, including background checks. It requires employers to obtain written consent from candidates before conducting a background check and provides individuals with certain rights, such as the right to dispute inaccurate information.

Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC): The EEOC provides guidance on how background checks should be conducted in a fair and non-discriminatory manner. They emphasize the importance of considering individual circumstances, such as rehabilitation efforts and avoiding practices that disproportionately impact certain groups.

Some states and cities have also passed their own employment laws that must also be adhered to. It's important for hiring managers to know which guidance to apply and in what situations.

Sample Background Check Policy Download the Template 

Ensure Fairness and Compliance with Consistency

By establishing clear guidelines and practices, organizations can minimize bias and ensure that all candidates are evaluated without discrimination. Some HR practices to consider include:

Developing Clear Background Check Policies: Written policies and procedures for background checks should also include what information will be considered, how it will be verified, and how results will be evaluated.

Training HR Staff on Fair and Consistent Evaluation:  HR staff must be trained on unconscious bias, fair evaluation techniques, and the importance of consistency in applying background check criteria.

Handling Inconsistent or Inaccurate Information: Strategies for verifying and cross-checking information obtained during background checks must also be addressed, including discrepancies and opportunities for candidates to provide explanations or clarifications.

Incorporating Diversity and Inclusion:  To create a more inclusive hiring process, consider incorporating DEI principles into employment background check practices. Recognize the unique challenges faced by certain groups and implement alternative evaluation methods.

Ensuring Continuous Improvement and Evaluation: Regularly assess hiring practices and seek feedback from candidates and employees. Adapt or change processes to ensure fairness, accuracy, and compliance with changing laws and regulations.

The Impact of Unfair Background Checks

When candidates face unfair discrimination based on their past mistakes or circumstances, the result could be disqualification from job opportunities despite their skill levels and potential for growth. Employers often face lawsuits from discriminatory background checks that are costly and time-consuming, not to mention the damage they can do to the organization's reputation. 

Understanding and adhering to federal and state laws, such as the FCRA and EEOC guidelines, is essential for HR professionals. By staying up-to-date with changing regulations and ensuring compliance, HR professionals can create a fair and inclusive hiring process that benefits both candidates and the organization in the long run.


Get Email Notifications